Former President Donald Trump raised eyebrows last month after announcing he was selling special edition “God Bless the USA” bibles.
The holy books, themed after country music musician Lee Greenwood’s patriotic anthem, include more than simply Christian scriptures: The special edition bibles also include text from secular sources such as the United States Constitution, the Pledge of Allegiance, and the chorus of the titular Greenwood song.
Fox News Digital contacted Christian leaders and apologists of various denominations to get their reactions to the unorthodox bible sale.
The first question raised by critics when the bibles were announced was whether it was appropriate for a politician to make such sales during a campaign season.
Daniel Darling, the director of Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary’s Land Center for Cultural Engagement, had mixed feelings about the campaign.
“Many Christians, even those like me who are very conservative both politically and theologically, thought his approach was a bit crass,” he told Fox News Digital.
“While many Christians are deeply patriotic and revere our nation’s documents, they are wary of mixing those things too closely inside the pages of a Bible.”
Darling said he doesn’t believe Trump was being malicious or intentionally irreverent to scripture but didn’t understand the optics.
“Trump selling this Bible seems a bit commercial, though I doubt he intended to offend Christians. He likely thought he was doing a good thing,” said Darling. “But a Bible endorsed by any politician smacks of syncretism and an over-the-top civil religion that cheapens the Bible when it’s used as a political prop.”
Fr. Brian Graebe, a priest with the Archdiocese of New York who holds a doctorate in theology from the Pontifical Gregorian University in Rome, similarly told Fox News Digital that while selling bibles and encouraging scriptural literacy is good, the Trump-centric advertising is off-putting.
“My concern is not so much that there are Bibles being offered and sold and purchased — that’s fine,” said Graebe. “The more bibles that are out there and the more people read it, the better. That’s an objective good. I think the troubling aspect here is […] the marketing of it, the Americanization of it, the Trump-ification of it.”
He added, “Is the Trump Bible more Trump than Bible? I think that’s a key question that we need to ask ourselves to see what the ultimate objective here is.”
Including secular documents in the “God Bless the USA” bibles was controversial. While texts such as the Declaration of Independence and Pledge of Allegiance make passing reference to a “Creator” and “God,” they are not necessarily religiously centred documents.
The U.S. Constitution is also included within the Bible’s covers, which at no point acknowledges God at all.
Joe Heschmeyer, an apologist at Catholic Answers, told Fox News Digital that the Catholic Church is generally adverse to “patriotic appropriations of Christianity that seek to turn the Gospel into fodder for a political campaign or a social movement.”
To him, urinating civic documents into the same pages as the Christian canon was insufficiently reverent of scripture.
“The Hebrew word for ‘holy’ is qadosh, which means ‘separate’ or ‘set apart.’ The idea is that some places, times, and things belong to God, apart from ordinary worldly use,” Heschmeyer said. “We wouldn’t put soda in the Chalice from Mass, or use the church as a gymnasium, and it’s why we don’t want to do anything that blends the sacred and the secular in the Holy Bible.”
