Public criticism sometimes produces something more useful than an exchange of accusations: direct engagement between the person raising questions and the office holder expected to answer them. That opportunity arose after my open letter to Nigeria’s Minister of Power, Chief Joseph Olasunkanmi Tegbe, titled “We Have Heard This Before: Nigerians Need Electricity, Not Another Performance of Promises.”
The letter was written in the public interest. It questioned the familiar pattern of ministerial assurances in the electricity sector, examined some of the Minister’s public statements and challenged the tendency to present isolated improvements as evidence of wider transformation. It was not an indictment of his personal integrity. It was an interrogation of public responsibility and of the performance expected from an office that touches virtually every aspect of national life.
I had no reason to anticipate what followed.
The Call From Joseph Olasunkanmi Tegbe
On noticing a missed call from the Minister’s number, I returned it without hesitation. I did not want my silence to suggest I was unwilling to engage with the person whose statements I had examined.
He answered. After a brief exchange, I introduced myself. His immediate question was direct: was I the author of the open letter that had gone viral across media platforms?
I acknowledged authorship.
The conversation quickly became a challenge. The Minister asked why I had written the letter without first reading his earlier rebuttal in a press interview. I explained that I was unaware of the interview. Had I seen it, I would have considered its explanations before publication.
He expressed displeasure at what he described as a tendency among Nigerian writers to destroy reputations. I took exception to the generalisation. Writers and journalists should not be lumped together in that manner, and my letter had not impugned his credibility. It had examined a statement attributed to him in the public domain, particularly his account of communities that had reportedly moved from prolonged darkness to as much as 18 hours of electricity supply.
There is a fundamental distinction between questioning a public statement and attacking the character of the person who made it. Public office holders must recognise that distinction, just as journalists must understand the responsibility that comes with publishing criticism.
Context, Evidence and the Right of Reply
The Minister said he had granted interviews to explain his position but complained that journalists twist his statements. I responded that context can shape interpretation. That makes context important, but it does not remove the obligation to interrogate statements by public officials, especially on matters of considerable public interest.
During the conversation, he offered to send materials to help me verify his position. I encouraged him to do so. He forwarded social media content, including satirical and critical reactions to his freezer remark, and a YouTube video containing a favourable assessment of improvements in electricity supply.
I have examined the materials. The social media commentary reflects the scepticism and humour with which some members of the public received his statement. The video presents a positive testimonial from an individual who believes improved supply is making a difference to businesses and consumers.
Both reactions deserve acknowledgement. Neither is a comprehensive assessment of the national electricity situation. A critical post does not establish that no improvement has occurred. Equally, one consumer’s testimonial cannot establish that the crisis has been overcome.
There is an important qualification. Although the Minister referred to an earlier press interview, he did not forward it, its transcript or details of its contents. I have therefore not examined that rebuttal, and I would be willing to consider it if it is made available. A fair hearing requires that the substance of a person’s explanation be examined rather than presumed.
Why the Minister of Power Nigeria Should Welcome Questions
That is the spirit in which I regard the call. The Minister expressed his displeasure and explained why he considered the open letter premature. I explained the basis of my intervention and defended the legitimacy of the questions raised. Neither of us needed to abandon his position for the conversation to be useful.
I consider the willingness of a public office holder to engage directly with criticism a development worth acknowledging. Public office is not merely the occupation of a position or the exercise of authority. It carries an obligation to respond to matters of public concern. A minister need not agree with every critic, but citizens are entitled to explanations, and those entrusted with public responsibility should not regard questions as personal affronts.
Responsiveness is not a substitute for performance, however. It is one of the obligations that accompany public office.
I also reiterated a point I consider important for the Minister at this stage of his assignment. He must guard against being carried away by applause from praise singers. There will always be individuals eager to celebrate a minister, just as others will ridicule every action. Neither group should determine the direction of public policy.
His responsibility is to face the work before him with greater commitment and address the persistent instability of electricity supply. He should be more concerned about the consumer who cannot plan a business around unreliable power than about the commentator who praises or criticises his statements.
The Nigeria Electricity Crisis Is Bigger Than Public Perception
The Nigeria electricity crisis is too consequential to be reduced to a contest over perception. It affects manufacturing, commerce, healthcare, education, household expenditure and the productivity of the national economy. For millions of Nigerians, electricity is not an abstract policy debate. It determines whether a business stays open, whether food is preserved, whether a hospital can operate effectively and whether a student can study without interruption.
The Minister may well have inherited a difficult sector. The constraints are real: inadequate gas supply, financial liabilities, transmission bottlenecks, distribution weaknesses, vandalism, metering deficits and regulatory challenges. But these difficulties are not new discoveries. Successive administrations have identified them, announced interventions and offered assurances. The public is entitled to ask what is different this time and what measurable improvements will follow.
His reported account of improved supply in some communities deserves verification, not dismissal. Repairs to transmission infrastructure and the return of generating units to service also deserve recognition where operational evidence supports the claims. But the Ministry must go further by publishing reliable information on the locations benefiting from improved supply, the duration of that improvement, generation levels, distribution allocations and the progress of outstanding repairs.
The country needs a clear distinction between temporary restoration and sustainable improvement. It needs to know what has been completed, what remains in progress and what obstacles are delaying delivery. Above all, consumers need to experience the difference in their homes, businesses and communities.
Joseph Olasunkanmi Tegbe and the Obligation to Deliver
My original letter remains relevant. The telephone conversation does not invalidate the questions it raised, just as the questions do not invalidate the Minister’s right to explain his actions. Where a minister believes his statements have been misrepresented, he should provide the relevant context and supporting information. Where a journalist raises questions, the office holder should be prepared to respond. Where evidence shows an account was inaccurate, it should be corrected. That is how responsible public discourse should function.
I do not regard the Minister’s call as an answer to the electricity crisis. Nor should he regard a favourable video or supportive comments as evidence that the work is done. The real verdict will come from consumers whose supply becomes dependable, whose businesses can operate without the constant expense of alternative power and whose lives are no longer organised around the uncertainty of the next outage.
Chief Tegbe has an opportunity to make a difference. I would rather see him succeed in delivering sustained improvements than become another name in the succession of ministers who diagnosed the problems but could not overcome them. That is not a concession. It is an expression of what Nigerians stand to gain if the assignment is successfully discharged.
The call has opened a channel of engagement. I remain willing to examine further information he may provide, including the press interview to which he referred. But the central issue is unchanged.
A minister may explain his performance, and the public must be prepared to hear him. A journalist may raise uncomfortable questions, and the office holder must be prepared to answer them. In the end, however, neither the explanation nor the argument will keep the lights on.
Electricity must.